Bateson, Double Description, Todes, and Embodiment: Preparing Activities and Their Relation to Abduction
JOHN SHOTTER
First published: 29 May 2009 https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-5914.2009.00399.xCitations: 21
John Shotter
the new ISO standard on governance is heavily influenced by VSM and the UK government’s initiative on managing complex projects – ‘Project X’ has VSM at the core of its governance model: https://www.apm.org.uk/media/42426/developing-the-practice-of-governance-report_final.pdf You don’t really get more mainstream acceptance than an ISO standard.
APM Developing the practice of governance final report December 2019 https://www.apm.org.uk/media/42426/developing-the-practice-of-governance-report_final.pdf
Reductionist metaphysics resembles the medieval ‘Great Chain of Being’, stepping from leptons and quarks (or perhaps superstrings?) through atoms, molecules, cells, organisms, populations and finally ecologies/economies.
Reductionist metaphysics resembles the medieval 'Great Chain of Being', stepping from leptons and quarks (or perhaps superstrings?) through atoms, molecules, cells, organisms, populations and finally ecologies/economies.
In today’s post, I am looking at difference. Difference is a big concept in Cybernetics. As Ross Ashby noted:
The most fundamental concept in cybernetics is that of “difference”, either that two things are recognizably different or that one thing has changed with time.
In Cybernetics, the goal is to eliminate the difference. If we take an example of a steersman on a boat, they are continuously trying to correct their course so that they can reach their destination correctly. The course has set the path, and any difference due to environmental conditions or other things will need to be corrected. This is a negative feedback cycle, where the current value is compared against a set value, and any difference will trigger an action from the steersman. If the steersman has enough variety, in terms of experience or technology, they can easily correct the difference.
This is part 1 of a series where Christofer investigates the ideas of David Chapman with his friend Jake Orthwein. The material covered is mainly from Chapman’s two books: ‘Meaningness’ (meaningness.com) and ‘In the Cells of the Eggplant’ (metarationality.com).
In the first episode they focus on problematic cognitivist assumptions that undergird much of Deutsch’s critical rationalism. They talk about Heidegger’s idea of coping with the world, the relationship between cognition, perception and action, how representations get their meaning, and how Wittgenstein got some shit right.
Jake Orthwein is a writer and filmmaker based in Santa Monica, CA. He studied film and cognitive science at the University of Southern California and currently works as Director of Media for the Psychology of Technology Institute, an academic non-profit focused on improving research on the human-technology relationship. He is also a long term meditator.
10Webinar – Systems approaches to strengthening health system resilience: Key concepts and lessons from COVID-19Date: February 10, 2022 12:09 PM – 2:00 PM CETOnline event: https://unige.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_AdqMGV4aSWuyxATZAK7OMQDropdownAdd to calendar10Days21Hours10Minutes05Seconds
Save the date!!
On 10 February 2022, 13:00 – 14:00 CET join us for the webinar: Systems approaches to strengthening health system resilience: Key concepts and lessons from COVID-19.
The seminar will present the key concepts of health system resilience and stages of a shock as they relate to systems thinking, and will discuss strategies for building resilience from the evidence and lessons learned during COVID-19 in the European region.
Facilitators:
Prof. Karl Blanchet, Geneva Centre of Humanitarian Studies, and Dr Dell Saulnier, Lund University, Co-leads of SYSTAC European Hub.
Panellists:
Prof. Steve Thomas Trinity College Dublin. Prof. Thomas is the Edward Kennedy Professor of Health Policy and Management and Director of Health Policy and Engagement for the School of Medicine. He is the lead author of the ’Strengthening health systems resilience: Key concepts and strategies’ report from the European Observatory.
Jullien views propensity in Chinese philosophy, as a counterpart to causality in Western philosophy. Some unpacking of his writing in digests may be helpful.
Jullien, François. 1995. The Propensity of Things: Toward a History of Efficacy in China. Translated by Janet Lloyd. Zone Books.
Introduction
How can we conceive of the dynamic in terms of the static, in terms of “disposition”? Or, to put it another way, how can any static situation be simultaneously conceived in terms of historical movement? [p. 11]
A Confusing Ambiguity: The WordShi
A single Chinese word, shi1`will serve as our guide as we reflect on this matter, even though it is a relatively common term gen erally given no philosophical significance. The word is itself a source of confusion, but it was out of that confusion that this book emerged. [pp. 11-12]
Do you want to learn the basics of the System Dynamics method and how this can be used to explain how change takes place, why people misunderstand change, and why so many policies fail to solve problems? Free Online Course GEO-SD662 opens February 1.
Highly engaging two-session online leadership workshop (31 Mar & 7 Apr) drawing on the ground-breaking work of systems theorist, Barry Oshry
About this event
Times of great disruption and volatility are also moments of great possibility and transformation. To realise the potential of this moment we must strengthen two critical leadership capacities:
Leading Self – how to bring greater awareness, compassion and insight to turbulent situations; and
Leading Systems – how to skilfully navigate and lead amidst the messiness and complexity of human systems.
These workshops combine a rare combination of frameworks and practices that will deepen both your personal insight and your systems sight.
We draw on the profound and practical thinking of systems theorist, Barry Oshry, and his five decades of research into the nature of human systems and the drivers of human behaviour. One of the revelations in Oshry’s work is that many of the problems we believe are primarily personal or interpersonal – “I’m not effective in my role”, “If only I had a better manager (partner/Prime Minister/President) then things would be fine”, “We are not a good team” – are not just personal. Context matters too. Many of us don’t see our contexts and the power of context to shape consciousness and behaviour. This blindness to context increases blame, kills trust, and corrodes potentially supportive and productive relationships. We get stuck.
This online workshop includes two highly engaging, enjoyable and thought-provoking sessions spaced a week apart to allow you to immediately apply the frameworks and practices in your everyday working life.
When?
Session 1, 0900-1130 BST, Thursday 31 March
Session 2, 0900-1300 BST, Thursday 7 April
The workshop fee covers both sessions.
Session 1, 0900-1130 BST, Thursday 31 March
What to expect?
Online simulation that replicates the leadership contexts within which we work everyday. This experiential exercise becomes a platform to explore the nature of context in human systems and its impact on behaviour.
Frameworks to help you distinguish between personal and system dynamics.
Immediate application of the framework to your situation.
Outcomes
Recognise four key systemic contexts in human systems and how these shape behaviour.
Learn to spot predictable patterns of behaviour that limit organistional effectiveness.
Identify specific habitual behaviours that limit your effectiveness.
Increase your awareness of the interplay between self and system.
Session 2, 0900-1300 BST, Thursday 7 April
What to expect?
Engaging organisational exercise where participants enter a fast-moving, turbulent environment as either a top executive, middle manager, worker or customer working together on important shared tasks. The experience productively challenges taken-for-granted assumptions about what it means to lead yourself and lead systems.
Practices to bring together diverse stakeholders and rapidly generate a rich picture of the whole system.
Frameworks to expand your perspective and see more clearly what is personal and what is systemic.
Outcomes
Generate greater awareness and choice in how you lead yourself and the systems of which you are a part.
Increase your empathy for others, extending your ability to effectively partner with a wider range of stakeholders.
Learn to see underlying conditions & patterns of interacting that create misunderstandings, tensions and conflict in teams and organisations.
Where?
Online on Zoom
What does it cost?
Standard fee: £250 plus VAT (UK sales tax)
Reduced fee: £150 plus VAT (UK sales tax)
The workshop fee cover both sessions: on 31 March and 7 April.
We aim to offer our programmes to a wider range of people and organisations, including in different regions of the world. To widen accessibility to our programmes we offer a reduced fee option. Please choose the fee that fits your economic circumstances.
What do clients say about our online workshops?
“A game changer in online experiential learning”
“The possibility to empower ourselves in any moment by ‘seeing’ our emergent responses and then asking what our ‘creative contributions’ might be.
“Simple yet impactful.”
“Very apt and applicable to all types of organizations”
“Exceptional online learning – I was immediately able to see opportunities to grow and build on my work and the projects and teams I am working with.”
“Experiential, immersive, illuminating.”
John Watters is a Founding Director of Living Leadership and one of the world’s leading authorities on systems theorist Barry Oshry’s work. John had the joy and privilege of a twenty-year collaboration and partnership with Barry Oshry accrediting trainers, consultants and coaches worldwide and introducing Oshry’s work into Europe and to organisations as diverse as UNESCO, NATO, Shell, Roche, public sector bodies, global and local charities.
John’s leadership and organisational consultancy work focuses on connecting individuals, teams and whole systems with their full potential. John specialises in facilitating breakthrough on complex issues and finding common ground in stuck and conflicted situations. In doing this work he pays special attention to holding space for our full humanity to be present, creating conditions to get to the heart of the issue and strengthening our capacity to listen deeply to ourselves, others and the whole system. Clients describe John’s way of working as courageous, challenging, warm-hearted and inspiring. John lives in Shoreham-by-Sea, UK.
Lauren Isla is an Associate of Future Considerations and a Director of Hope, Curiosity, Determination. Lauren is accredited in Barry Oshry’s Organisation Workshop and has delivered client programs using this framework in Vietnam, Cambodia, Hong Kong, Jakarta, Singapore and Bangladesh.
Lauren helps organizations map out where they are against an ideal of having leaders and teams connecting, communicating and collaborating regularly across functions. Using proprietary tools and processes she helps organisations find out if their leaders and teams are networking as they should. Lauren’s spatial intelligence, analytical mind and ability to recognize patterns serve her in good stead as a Social Network Analyst (SNA). Trained by Valdis Krebs, a US-based consultant specializing in organisational network analysis, her work in SNA has provided the leaders of client organizations with insights into gaps in connections among and between their employees, teams and departments, allowing them to map and measure the amount of teamwork, communication, information flow, and knowledge-sharing that happens – or not – within their company, team, department, division or group. Lauren lives in Manila in the Philippines.
Other testimonials about our work:
“Working with John Watters has been among the most productive partnerships I have known”. Barry Oshry PhD, Author of Seeing Systems, Unlocking the Mysteries of Organizational Life
“It is easy to underestimate the power of Oshry’s work until you have taken this workshop. It was a life changing experience. You will find instant applications to your personal and professional life”. Seema Malhotra, Member of Parliament for Feltham & Weston, UK
Schools and the pandemic: Simulation model allows for safe operation
Developed during the ongoing pandemic, but adaptable to different needs: Austrian scientists develop simulation model for keeping schools open safely during a pandemic.Peer-Reviewed Publication
next Systems at Play Meetup with a great long time Systems Thinker, Gene Bellinger
When:
Thursday, February 24, 2022:
12:00 PM to 1:30 PM AEDT
Where:
Systems at Play Community – Free Online Event
We are excited to announce next Systems at Play Meetup with a great long time Systems Thinker, Gene Bellinger
When: Thursday, February 24, 2022: 12:00 PM to 1:30 PM AEDT Where: Systems at Play Community – Free Online Event
Gene will share his insights from more than four decades of experience and musings. And they’re not just any insights — these are learnings that, after his own reflection, he has found have served him well in his career. Gene is a storyteller, so you’ll have the chance to learn in an interesting way, and explore how constituent parts of systems interrelate and how those systems work over time. This will reveal implications related to the ‘disciplines’ in the CHOL community, which can ultimately have a positive impact on your organisation’s culture.
About the Speaker
Gene Bellinger is a highly respected member of the systems thinking community, the author of hundreds of models and articles, creating over 1,500 videos about relationships and their implications, and from time to time a member of the System Dynamics Society. Gene spent several years working with the developers of both Insight Maker and Kumu. In 2013, he co-authored “Beyond Connecting the Dots: Modeling for Meaningful Results” with Scott Fortmann-Roe, the developer of Insight Maker.
We Look forward to seeing you at the meetup and your participation in the discussion.
It takes a huge operation to get sufficient, safe, nutritious food to all of us. Although the food system touches our lives every day, we see only a minute part of it.
My piece jointly with Kate Cooper of the Birmingham Food Council:
System approaches in governmental public health: Findings from an analysis of the literature
Jason M. Orr,Jonathon P. Leider,Margaret J. Gutilla
First published: 28 December 2021
You must be logged in to post a comment.