announcing The Necessary Tangle – a living evidence atlas of systems | cybernetics | complexity

Update — 24 October 2026. The Necessary Tangle now has developed reading guides on OrgLens, 42 The Systemic Review, and systems leadership and action, alongside current events and calendar subscriptions. You can send a rough thought or correction through Quick contribute, without an account, with an optional private email for follow-ups. Read the 0.34 update. The announcement below describes the August launch; the atlas itself carries the current coverage and its limits.

I’ve been wanting for years to do a ‘better map’ of systems | complexity | cybernetics, having strongly criticised the Castellani ‘complexity map’ and seen some others – and been involved in the SCiO SysBoK where we tried to map key concepts, their necessary antecedents and dependent thingummies, people, meaning, and so on (- and always inspired by ‘rock family trees’ and the way it’s the constellation of influences and people around individual practitioners that actually makes the difference, as David Ing says).

So with the assistance of ChatGPT, and I’ve been building The Necessary Tangle – a living, evidence-backed atlas of systems | complexity | cybernetics.

At the August launch, it mapped 411 public entries and 32 developed profiles from 93 registered sources.

The key difference from the usual family tree is that every line has to say what sort of relationship it represents: logical antecedent, historical precursor, documented influence, teaching, collaboration, practical use, and so on.

The eventual ambition to: trace the human as well as conceptual lineages; connect theory to practice; distinguish espoused intellectual genealogy from the clusters the evidence actually produces; and let categories emerge from the resulting network rather than deciding the schools in advance.

It’s very much a public alpha. Some areas are already quite deep; others are little more than markers saying ‘this belongs here’. I’m putting it out now precisely because corrections, missing connections, rival genealogies and ‘surely you can’t say that’ responses are part of building it.

AND I’m very happy to share, collaborate or whatever….

Have a look
https://transduction.systems

Benjamin
www.antlerboy.com

Survey of Riffs and Rotes • 1

There’s a study called generalized primes which investigates in a more general way the relationship between arbitrary elements called primes and the composites which can be formed from them according to specified rules of composition.  Comparisons can be made among a variety of numerical systems or any orders of combinatorial species one might imagine.  I seem to recall at least one old monograph by Rademacher on the subject.

My fascination with questions like that led me many years ago to the Riff and Rote trick, a special case of the Make A Picture trick.  There’s a bit on that in the first article below.

Wiki Hub

Blog Dialogs

Blog Series

Excursions

Expositions

Explorations

cc: Academia.edu • Cybernetics • Laws of Form • Mathstodon • SeqFan
cc: Research Gate • Structural Modeling • Systems Science • Syscoi

#arithmetic, #combinatorics, #graph-theory, #group-theory, #logic, #mathematics, #number-theory, #riffs-and-rotes

The Equilibrium of Delay – 42 The Systemic Review (2026)

42 The Systemic Review examines a recurring capital-works backlog in the City of Playford, Australia: commitments, partial delivery, and work carried forward. The paper contrasts conventional capacity and project-management remedies with a systemic diagnosis of the relationships between demand, commitments, delivery capability, and feedback. It is an application of the publisher’s systems framework to a particular case; its interpretation and proposed interventions should be assessed against the underlying council evidence, not treated as established findings solely because they are presented as systems principles.

Read ‘The Equilibrium of Delay’ at 42 The Systemic Review (16 September 2026); browse the collection. Related SysCoI coverage: 42 The Systemic Review directory.

VSM-Diagnose-Tool – Dethloff / Ordo Novus (2026)

Ordo Novus has launched a free German-language organisational diagnosis tool drawing on Stafford Beer’s Viable System Model, announced by Conny Dethloff in November 2026. The application uses 57 questions in eight themes to suggest hypotheses relating to 18 structural, functional and communication-channel pathologies. It offers a management summary and possible areas for action. These are prompts for diagnosis, not independently validated organisational findings. Dethloff states that answers remain on the user’s own computer and that the tool works offline; those technical claims have not been independently tested.

Use the VSM-Diagnose-Tool (Ordo Novus); read Conny Dethloff’s launch announcement.

Critical Systems Thinking – Nobody has the full picture – Kemp (2026)

Andrea Kemp considers Critical Systems Heuristics and boundary critique as ways to investigate power and value in place-based work. Drawing on experience in health commissioning and community provision, she asks who defines a system, whose interests are included, and who gets to decide what counts as value for the voluntary, community, faith and social enterprise sector. The article is a reflection on methods she is exploring for research, rather than a report of tested results.

Read the original article by Andrea Kemp, published 13 November 2026.

A ‘Good Regulator Theorem’ for Embodied Agents – Virgo et al. (2025)

Nathaniel Virgo, Martin Biehl, Manuel Baltieri, and Matteo Capucci revisit the Conant–Ashby good regulator theorem from the standpoint of embodied agents. They develop a formulation in which an observer can interpret a successful regulator as updating beliefs about its environment. The notion of a ‘model’ is observer-dependent rather than necessarily a literal internal representation; the possible model may also be trivial.

The paper addresses the familiar tension between models as internal mechanisms and models attributed through an observer’s interpretation. It does not establish that every effective regulator contains a detailed explicit representation of the world.

Original paper: ‘A “Good Regulator Theorem” for Embodied Agents’ (arXiv:2508.06326v2, 21 August 2025; CC BY 4.0). Authors: Nathaniel Virgo, Martin Biehl, Manuel Baltieri, and Matteo Capucci. For an earlier, different critique, see ‘Fixing The Good Regulator Theorem’ – John Wentworth (2021), already covered on SysCoI.

Neighbourhood Health and Care: Building the System Before the Structure – 42 The Systemic Review (2026)

A September 2026 paper from 42 The Systemic Review, a SCiO publication, applies systems-theory principles to the development of neighbourhood health and care in England and Wales, with particular attention to Directors of Public Health and the relationships between services, governance, and local populations.

Its central concern is whether neighbourhood working is being designed as a viable set of relationships and capabilities, rather than first creating organisational structures and expecting integration to follow. The paper offers a framework-led diagnosis and proposed interventions. Its claims and interpretations should be assessed against the underlying evidence and local circumstances, rather than treated as settled findings.

Read the complete paper, ‘Neighbourhood Health and Care: Building the System Before the Structure’ (42 The Systemic Review, 1 September 2026). See also the existing SysCoI introduction to 42 The Systemic Review.

Proposed SCiO Special Interest Group: Systems and Cybernetics of Cybersecurity – Hart (2026)

SCiO has announced a proposed special interest group convened by Duncan Hart on applying systems thinking and cybernetics to cybersecurity. Hart suggests exploring organisational security through requisite variety, the Viable System Model, governance, and second-order cybernetics, rather than treating security solely as a collection of technical controls and compliance checks.

The invitation is open to security practitioners, systems practitioners, researchers, and people working in governance and oversight. An initial informal online meeting is proposed, but the announcement does not specify a meeting date. Anyone interested is invited to contact the organiser through the source announcement.

Source: Duncan Hart, ‘Proposed SCiO Special Interest Group: Systems and Cybernetics of Cybersecurity’, SCiO, 9 November 2026.

Teaching Meaning – Moore-Anderson with Raghavan (2026)

Christian Moore-Anderson joins Laksh Raghavan for episode 43 of the Cyb3rSyn Labs Podcast, Teaching Meaning. The host’s accompanying account, published on 26 July 2026, describes a conversation about second-order cybernetics, enactivism, and how understanding develops through teaching, conversation, and feedback.

Read Laksh Raghavan’s accompanying introduction and reflections.

Moore-Anderson is speaking at the SCiO UK Virtual Open Meeting on Monday 16 November 2026, 18:30–21:00 GMT, alongside Sean Manion. The meeting is free, online, and open to all. Register here.

Related reading from Manion: ‘Moon of the Unforgotten’ – Origin story of the term ‘Artificial Intelligence’.

Towards Meta-Renormalisation: The Social Basic – Amonya (2026)

[When can we describe a social pattern at a larger scale without losing the relations that make it possible? Amonya takes the physicist’s problem of renormalisation – what survives a change of scale – and adds an awkward feature of social life. People do not merely adapt within institutions; through their actions they can alter the rules, classifications and capacities that shape later adaptation.

The paper is more precise than its abstract might suggest. Its ‘Social Basic’ is an embodied person within historically formed relations, not an isolated atom. ‘Dynamical quadratic’ names a recursive explanatory problem, not a quadratic mathematical law. Most usefully, equations (6)–(8), on pages 5–6, set out a test for coarse-grained closure: do evolving the fine-grained process and then aggregating, and aggregating first and then evolving the coarse description, preserve the same selected consequences? The diagram on page 6 makes that distinction visible.

Amonya also separates the participants’ own operative descriptions from the analyst’s categories and subsequent model revisions (section 7). That is where the second-order cybernetic interest lies. The paper provides formal conditions for assessing a proposed social description, but not yet a worked social renormalisation analysis: the scale transformation, relevant measures, empirical tolerances, fixed points and possible universality would still have to be established in a particular case. Nor does successful coordination imply legitimacy; power and coercion remain part of the explanation. This is a research programme with a useful test, not a demonstrated new law of social scale.]

The paper

FD Amonya, Towards Meta-Renormalisation: The Social Basic (University of Birmingham, October 2026, nine-page preprint). The ‘dynamical quadratic’ describes the reciprocal reshaping of social conduct and the conditions of further adaptation (section 3). The ‘Social Basic’ denotes the embodied, relationally constituted and adapting person (section 4). Sections 5–7 specify state representations, fine and coarse transitions, an exact and approximate closure criterion, and the distinction between participants’ operative interpretations and the analyst’s model updates. The author explicitly leaves substantive social renormalisation results and empirical validation to future applications.

Related reading

How systems transform – Kania (2025)

John Kania’s September 2025 essay for the Centre for Exponential Change outlines five beliefs about systems transformation, particularly the place of structural change, relationships, trauma, and non-linearity. These are the author’s arguments, not empirical findings established by the SysCoI linklog.

Source: How systems transform – John Kania, 11 September 2025, Centre for Exponential Change.

https://centreforexponentialchange.org/how-systems-transform/

Toward an Ontology for Third Generation Systems Thinking – Levenchuk (2023)

In this 2023 paper, Anatoly Levenchuk examines how systems thinking has developed and what an ontology for a proposed third generation might need. The abstract frames systems thinking around nested, interacting systems, their environments, and the boundaries between them. This is the author’s proposed framing, rather than an agreed classification of generations of systems thinking.

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11524

Facing Complexity: Prediction vs. Adaptation – Gershenson (2011)

Carlos Gershenson’s 2011 paper asks when prediction and optimisation are appropriate, and when adaptation is a better response to a changing or unpredictable problem space. He argues that a solution optimised for a stable problem may become obsolete when conditions change, particularly where acting on the problem alters it. A useful short introduction to the distinction between trying to predict complexity and organising to adapt to it.

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/1112.3843

Riffs and Rotes, Finite Partial Functions • Overview

Riffs and Rotes are two species of graph-theoretic structure in a mathematical framework which establishes a bijective Gödel numbering between the positive integers (\mathbb{N}^{+}) and finite partial functions mapping \mathbb{N}^{+} to \mathbb{N}^{+}.  This framework strips away the standard arithmetic properties of numbers to reveal their “purely combinatorial” structure through doubly recursive prime factorization.

The Core Concept: From Primes to Functions

Every positive integer has a unique factorization as a product of primes (The Fundamental Theorem of Arithmetic).  Because every prime number has a unique index, e.g. p_1 = 2, p_2 = 3, p_3 = 5, we can recursively decompose both the bases and the exponents of any number into their respective prime indices.

By mapping these recursive index structures, a natural number is transformed into a set of ordered pairs — effectively a finite partial function (\mathbb{N}^+ \to \mathbb{N}^+).

Riffs vs. Rotes

The finite partial functions may be visualized using two distinct graph-theoretic structures:

  • Riffs (Rooted Index-Functional Forests):  Represented as directed graphs (digraphs) where nodes reflect the exact recursive assignment of a prime index to its exponent.
  • Rotes (Rooted Odd Trees with only Exponent Symmetries):  Represented as undirected, rooted trees that embed the same structural information but map it into a simplified graphic form.

How the Mapping Works (Examples)

Using the basic rule where a prime factor p_{k}^{n} translates to the functional assignment of input k to output n, expressed as the ordered pair \langle k, n \rangle, numbers map directly to finite partial functions.  The first ten cases are shown in the following Table.

Integer, Factorization, Finite Partial Function

Because this construction is a strict bijection, every single positive integer maps to exactly one unique finite partial function, and every finite partial function has a unique integer address (Gödel number).  Detailed combinatorial properties and sequence data for these graphs are documented on the OEIS Wiki “Riffs and Rotes” page.

Reference

  • The above text is adapted from the Google AI Overview for “Riffs and Rotes” “Finite Partial Functions” (Nov 8, 2026).

Resource

cc: Academia.edu • Cybernetics • Laws of Form • Mathstodon (1) (2) • SeqFan
cc: Research Gate • Structural Modeling • Systems Science • Syscoi

#algebra, #arithmetic, #combinatorics, #computation, #graph-theory, #group-theory, #logic, #mathematics, #number-theory, #recursion, #representation, #riffs-and-rotes, #semiotics, #visualization

Models and Reality: How Did Models Divorced from Reality Become Epistemologically Acceptable? – Zaman (2020)

Models and Reality: How Did Models Divorced from Reality Become Epistemologically Acceptable? — Asad Zaman (2020), International Econometric Review, 12(1), pp. 24–49. DOI: 10.33818/ier.748128.

Zaman examines how economic models can come to be assessed for consistency with formal principles rather than how well their assumptions and outputs describe the world. He traces philosophical shifts in the understanding of scientific knowledge that, in his account, help explain the acceptance of models whose relationship to empirical reality is not tested.

A paper about economics, but an interesting provocation for systems modellers: what is a model being judged against, and what observations would show that it isn’t useful for its intended purpose? The argument is the author’s; the paper does not demonstrate that all models lack empirical testing.

Open-access full text (PDF).

Pay No Attention to the Model Behind the Curtain – Stark (2022)

Philip B. Stark, 2022. arXiv version 2, 25 August 2022.

Stark examines models used to support policy decisions when their assumptions lack a sound empirical basis. He questions treating unlike costs and benefits as comparable quantities, expressing every kind of uncertainty as a probability, and using parameters whose meaning is poorly supported. Examples concern earthquake risk, bird deaths near wind turbines, football penalty cards, gender bias in academia, and climate policy.

Original arXiv record · Read the full paper · Related journal publication