[When can we describe a social pattern at a larger scale without losing the relations that make it possible? Amonya takes the physicist’s problem of renormalisation – what survives a change of scale – and adds an awkward feature of social life. People do not merely adapt within institutions; through their actions they can alter the rules, classifications and capacities that shape later adaptation.
The paper is more precise than its abstract might suggest. Its ‘Social Basic’ is an embodied person within historically formed relations, not an isolated atom. ‘Dynamical quadratic’ names a recursive explanatory problem, not a quadratic mathematical law. Most usefully, equations (6)–(8), on pages 5–6, set out a test for coarse-grained closure: do evolving the fine-grained process and then aggregating, and aggregating first and then evolving the coarse description, preserve the same selected consequences? The diagram on page 6 makes that distinction visible.
Amonya also separates the participants’ own operative descriptions from the analyst’s categories and subsequent model revisions (section 7). That is where the second-order cybernetic interest lies. The paper provides formal conditions for assessing a proposed social description, but not yet a worked social renormalisation analysis: the scale transformation, relevant measures, empirical tolerances, fixed points and possible universality would still have to be established in a particular case. Nor does successful coordination imply legitimacy; power and coercion remain part of the explanation. This is a research programme with a useful test, not a demonstrated new law of social scale.]
The paper
FD Amonya, Towards Meta-Renormalisation: The Social Basic (University of Birmingham, October 2026, nine-page preprint). The ‘dynamical quadratic’ describes the reciprocal reshaping of social conduct and the conditions of further adaptation (section 3). The ‘Social Basic’ denotes the embodied, relationally constituted and adapting person (section 4). Sections 5–7 specify state representations, fine and coarse transitions, an exact and approximate closure criterion, and the distinction between participants’ operative interpretations and the analyst’s model updates. The author explicitly leaves substantive social renormalisation results and empirical validation to future applications.
- Full paper PDF (ResearchGate; human verification may be required)
- Paper on ResearchGate (DOI: 10.13140/RG.2.2.10045.01762)
- Paper on SSRN (abstract ID 7640258)
Related reading
- Jessica Flack, ‘Coarse-graining as a downward causation mechanism’ – already on SysCoI (2017; journal paper).
- Ian Hacking, ‘The looping effects of human kinds’ (1996) – how classifications interact with the people classified.
- Gabrielli and colleagues, ‘Network renormalization’ (2025) – an account of the technical difficulties in extending renormalisation beyond standard physical settings.